by Maxine Fischbein, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter
(AJNews) – While Jewish memories of the October 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attacks in Israel remain visceral, Jewish Calgary’s commemoration on the third anniversary, delivered on its promise that the evening – organized by Calgary Jewish Federation in partnership with the Beth Tzedec Congregation Jewish Film Festival and the Paperny Family JCC – would be a time for reflection and resilience.
Three years out, emotions remain raw after the slaughter of more than 1,100 Israelis; the kidnapping of 251 men, women and children held hostage in Gaza; the ensuing war in Gaza; and a subsequent spike in Jew hate around the world.
And yet, remarkable examples of Israeli resilience in the face of seemingly insurmountable grief are bubbling up to the surface, sources of pride and celebration.
Organizers set a tone that spoke to both the solemnity of the commemoration and hope for a better future for Israelis and the Jewish people.
Allies, including politicians, attended the commemoration, not to speak, but to sit beside us in our sorrow, lending support on an occasion too sacred for other agendas. Notable guests included Calgary Mayor Jeromy Farkas, City of Calgary Councillors Rob Ward (Ward 11) and Dan McLean (Ward 13), Calgary-Elbow MLA Samir Kayande and senior Calgary Police Service officials.
The highlight of the evening was the screening of Safe Room, a truly inspiring documentary which Harvey Cyngiser – founder and director of the Calgary Jewish Film Festival – offered to the community prior to this year’s festival knowing that it would be even more impactful as part of the October 7 commemoration.
The 2026 film, directed by Haley Geffen, tells a remarkable story of Israelis living in the Gaza envelope who were driven into their safe rooms as Hamas attacked their various communities on October 7, 2023.
Though not directly connected with one another, these courageous survivors were brought together thanks to the quick thinking of Dr. Gedalya Fendel, also living in the shadow of Gaza, who rushed toward danger to help triage the injured even as the attacks continued.
Fendel sent some of the survivors to his own home where his wife Merav, together with their children, welcome these traumatized people, including one very pregnant woman.
At the Fendel home, strangers formed family, creating something beautiful, even in the midst of tragedy.
Resiliency and hope were also explored prior to the screening, as Israeli ShinShiniyot Adva and Noam added their moving perspectives.
The duo, who are both 18, have deferred their military service to serve the Calgary Jewish community during shanat sherut, Hebrew for a year of service. (The ShinShin program, an initiative of the Jewish Agency for Israel, takes its name from the letter shin at the beginning of each word.)
Though not directly affected by the attacks on October 7, 2023, both Adva and Noam described how they were forever changed by what took place that day.
Explaining their role in Calgary, which began late this past summer, Adva told those assembled at the commemoration:
“Our role is to bring Israel—the beautiful side of it, but also the difficult, painful and complicated side. Our country has gone through three incredibly difficult years. Three years in which everything changed.”
Noam stated it bluntly:
“On October 7, I stopped being a teenager.”
Noam was visiting family members in Jerusalem who knew something was wrong when they began hearing their phones repeatedly ringing and saw notifications from Noam’s cousin who was serving in Military Intelligence near Israel’s border with Gaza. She let them know there had been mass casualties and that a war was beginning.
Turning on the TV, they couldn’t believe what they saw unfolding.
“Our minds simply couldn’t comprehend the scale of what was happening,” said Noam. “They still can’t.”
Then sirens warning of missile attacks began in Jerusalem.
“I felt unsafe and helpless,” recalled Noam. I was scared for my family who weren’t near me.”
Noam recounted how her mother drove for more than an hour through sirens and missile attacks to pick her up and take her home.
“We both cried the entire way,” Noam recalled.
In the wake of October 7, Noam said she and others threw themselves into volunteer efforts, feeding soldiers, collecting clothing, and making donations to help families whose loved ones had been taken hostage.
“For a long time, I didn’t feel like I could really continue living my life normally,” remembered Noam. “It didn’t feel fair when there were hostages, people who had been murdered, and soldiers suffering from trauma all around me. My heart was still in Gaza.”
Through a rollercoaster of emotions, including anger and survivor guilt, Noam says that, for her, “…two years passed almost on autopilot.”
“I was physically present, but when it came to the big milestones in my life, I felt like I didn’t have the right to celebrate them normally, with happiness.”
“When the last hostages came home, I felt like I could breathe again,” Noam said, though later adding, “I look back on October 7, and my heart breaks a little more every time.”
“This is the reality of being Israeli, seeing the worst and coming together as a society to try to make it better,” Noam said.
Like Noam, Adva was robbed of a carefree youth.
“The truth is that October 7 is a day none of us can ever go back from. There is life before October 7 and life after October 7,” Adva said.
“We all know someone who knows someone. Even though I was physically at home on October 7, my mind was not at home, and my heart was not at home either,” Adva added.
Adva characterized her October 7 story as “…the most hopeful in the world.”
“On October 7, I was sitting in my home with my family, protected and safe. Just as a 15-year-old girl should be,” added Adva. “There are many stories and many people who were deeply affected by this war. I can only hope that a hundred years from now, no one will have a more interesting story than mine.”
In a later conversation with AJNews, Adva and Noam spoke about how difficult it was for them to be so far away from Israel on October 7 and to write the words they so movingly shared with the 600 community members who attended the commemoration.
But they also felt the love.
“Seeing how many people showed up and cared about the topic, it was very comforting,” recalled Noam.
“We felt so supported,” Adva said.
Thanks to the efforts of Calgary Jewish Federation and the Jewish Agency for Israel, Adva and Noam’s work in Calgary is itself a sign of resiliency and hope for the future as they connect to our community, especially our youth, helping to reinforce Jewish identity and pride and bringing much-needed sunshine after the rain.



Be the first to comment on "Calgary’s commemoration of October 7 massacre included hope for the future"